Briefing document
This briefing document reviews the core tenets, historical context, and key philosophical concepts of the Nimbarka Sampradaya, with a particular focus on its Dvaitadvaita (dualistic monism) Vedanta philosophy.
1. Introduction to Nimbarka Sampradaya
The Nimbarka Sampradaya is a significant Vaishnava tradition within Hinduism, established by Srimat Nimbarkacharya. It is characterized by its unique philosophical doctrine of Dvaitadvaita (duality-in-unity) or Bhedabheda (difference and non-difference). This school of thought emphasizes the worship of Lord Krishna and Shri Radha, with Raganuga Bhakti (devotion based on spontaneous loving attachment) as its primary means of spiritual practice.
The Sampradaya is also known by several other names, including San Sampradaya, Sanaka Sampradaya, Chatur-San Sampradaya, or Hamsa Sampradaya. Traditional accounts state that the original teachers of this lineage were the four mind-born sons of Brahma: Sanaka, Sanandana, Sanatana, and Sanatkumara. The name "Hamsa Sampradaya" originates from the belief that Lord Narayana Himself, in the form of a swan (Hamsa), imparted the essence of truth to these four sages. The Vishnuyamala Tantra describes the guru-parampara (lineage of teachers) from Hamsa-Narayana to Nimbarkacharya, stating: "The eighteen-syllable mantra manifested from the lotus mouth of Narayana; it was received by the Kumara brothers, who gave it to Narada, and he, in turn, instructed his disciple Nimbarka. Thus, the eighteen-syllable mantra has been transmitted through this tradition."
2. Historical Context of Nimbarkacharya
While the exact historical details of Nimbarkacharya's life, including his period of appearance and birthplace, are not definitively established, he is considered by his followers to be very ancient. However, some scholars like Ramakrishna Bhandarkar, Rajendralal Mitra, and Dr. Rama Chaudhari place him after Ramanuja, Madhva, and Vallabhacharya. Conversely, George Grierson and Monier Williams suggest that Nimbarka Sampradaya is the oldest among the Vaishnava traditions.
Notably, Dr. Amarprasad Bhattacharya posited that Nimbarkacharya and his direct disciple, Srinivasacharya, appeared after the Buddhist philosopher Dharmakirti but before the Advaita exponent Shankaracharya, suggesting a time frame between the 6th and 7th centuries CE.
According to the Sampradaya's tradition, Nimbarkacharya was an incarnation of Lord Vishnu's Sudarshan Chakra (divine discus). His mother's name was Jayanti, and his father was the sage Arun. Discrepancies exist regarding his birthplace: Vedantaratnamanjusha indicates he was born in Andhra or Tailinga Desha on the banks of the Godavari River, at Sudarshanashrama or Arunashrama. Acharyacharitra states his birth in Vrindavan on the banks of the Yamuna, while Audumbara Samhita suggests Nimbagram near Govardhan. Despite these differing accounts, the view that he was born in Andhra Pradesh is considered more plausible. His birth is traditionally observed on Kartik Purnima.
3. Dvaitadvaita Vedanta: Core Philosophical Principles
Nimbarka's philosophy, primarily articulated in his concise Brahmasutra Bhashya titled Vedanta-Parijata Saurabha and further elaborated by his disciple Srinivasacharya in Vedanta Kaustubha, is a form of Bhedabhedavada.
3.1 Eligibility for Vedantic Study
According to Nimbarka's philosophy, individuals who are "गुरुभक्त, वैराग्यवान्, भगवत्कृपाकाङ्क्षी मुमुक्षु" (devoted to their guru, dispassionate, desirous of divine grace, and seeking liberation) become eligible for studying Vedanta after completing the study of the six Angas of the Vedas and Purva Mimamsa (Brahmasutra 1-1-1 Bhashya).
3.2 Tattva-Samiksha (Analysis of Realities): Brahma, Chit, and Achit
Nimbarka's system is "त्रित्ववादी" (tri-realist), postulating three fundamental realities: Brahma, Chit (conscious entities), and Achit (unconscious entities). Many of Nimbarka's principles align with those of Ramanuja.
Brahma: In Nimbarka's doctrine, Brahma is referred to as Krishna. Brahma, though devoid of homogeneous and heterogeneous distinctions (sajatiya and vijatiya bheda), possesses inherent distinctions (svagata bheda), meaning living beings (jiva) and the material world (jagat) are its internal differentiations. Therefore, Brahma is not nirvishesha (featureless) but savishesha (with attributes); it is not nirguna (without qualities) but saguna (with qualities). It is the source of both "terrible" (bhishana) and "sweet" (madhura) attributes. Omnipotence, rulership, etc., are its terrible qualities, while beauty, bliss, and compassion are its sweet qualities. Brahma is not inactive (kriyahin) as it is the creator, sustainer, and destroyer of the universe. It is both the efficient cause (nimitta karana) and the material cause (upadana karana) of the world, meaning the entire living and material world is its outcome. In these aspects, Nimbarka's views largely parallel Ramanuja's.
Chit (Jiva/Conscious Entity): Chit refers to conscious beings, i.e., individual souls (jivas). Jivas are characterized as being knowledge-स्वरूप (essentially knowledge) and knowing subjects (jnata), agents (karta), enjoyers (bhokta), atomic in size (anuparinama), numerous, infinite, and can be either bound or liberated based on their type.
Achit (Unconscious Entity): According to Nimbarka, Achit or inert matter is of three types: Prakrita (primordial matter), Aprakrita (pure substance), and Kala (time).
Prakrita: From Prakriti, the world is created in an ordered sequence (Mahat, etc.). The visible world arising from Prakriti is called Prakrita.
Aprakrita: This is a type of pure substance (shuddha tattva) within Achit. This Aprakrita Achit is the material cause of the divine bodies of Brahma and liberated souls, and of the objects found in Brahmaloka (the abode of Brahma).
Kala: Time, though inert (Achit), is without parts (ansh vihin) and all-pervading (vibhu), unchanging (aparinaami), and indestructible (avinashi). Up to this point, Nimbarka's and Ramanuja's views show little significant difference.
3.3 The Nature of Relationship: Bhedabheda (Difference and Non-difference)
The central point of distinction between Nimbarka and other Vedanta schools, particularly Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita, lies in the relationship between Brahma and the individual souls (jivas) and the world (jagat).
Nimbarka asserts that Brahma, Jiva, and Jagat are "स्वरुप में भिन्नाभिन्न" (simultaneously different and non-different in nature). This means they are both distinct and non-distinct.
Brahma is the cause, and Jiva-Jagat is the effect.
Brahma is the possessor of power (shaktiman), and Jiva-Jagat is the power (shakti).
Brahma is the whole (anshi), and Jiva-Jagat is the part (ansha).
Nimbarka uses the analogy of a clay pot (ghata) and clay (mritsapinda): "मिट्टी से एक घट बना हुआ है। मिट्टी कारण है और घट कार्य। घट मिट्टी का बना हुआ है। इसलिए उपादन की दृष्टि से दोनों अभिन्न है- एक ही है। किन्तु धट का एक भिन्न स्वरुप है-- जो मिट्टी में नहीं है। घट लाओ कहने पर कोई मिट्टी नहीं लाता। अत: धट एवं मिट्टी स्वरुप से परस्पर भिन्न भी है अभिन्न भी।" (A pot is made from clay. Clay is the cause, and the pot is the effect. The pot is made of clay, so from the perspective of the material, both are non-different—they are one. However, the pot has a distinct form that is not in the clay. If someone asks for a pot, they don't bring clay. Therefore, the pot and clay are both different and non-different in nature.)
Similarly, Brahma and Jiva-Jagat are different and non-different in terms of both their nature (svarupa) and their attributes (dharma).
Non-difference: As cause and effect, power and powerful, and whole and part, Brahma and Jiva-Jagat are non-different in their essence. Jivas and Jagat are real and eternal like Brahma. Jivas are conscious and blissful like Brahma.
Difference: However, Brahma's 'Brahmaness', the jiva's 'jivahood', and the world's 'worldliness' are distinct and not one. Brahma is Brahma; it is not a jiva or the world. Furthermore, not all qualities of Brahma are present in jivas or the world. Jivas are not creators, nor do they possess omnipresence (vibhutva) or indestructibility (avinashitva). Qualities like atomicity (anutva), desire-driven actions, and experience of results in jivas, and inertness (jaratva) in the world, are not present in Brahma. Hence, Brahma and Jiva-Jagat are also distinct.
Therefore, according to this philosophy, difference (bheda) and non-difference (abheda), duality and non-duality, are equally true, eternal, natural, and non-contradictory. This is why Nimbarka's doctrine is called Svabhavika Bhedabhedavada (natural difference-non-difference).
The key distinction from Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita is that while Ramanuja also accepts the truth of both difference and non-difference, he asserts that non-difference is more fundamentally true than difference. In Vishishtadvaita, jivas and the world, though different in attributes, are intrinsically non-different in their essence from Brahma. Nimbarka, however, posits an equal and simultaneous reality to both.
4. Mukti (Liberation) or Moksha
Nimbarka's concept of liberation has two aspects: attainment of the nature of Brahma (Brahmasvarupa labha) and realization of one's true self (Atmasvarupa labha).
When a seeker of liberation (mumukshu) becomes qualified through their spiritual practice, by the grace of Brahma, all their karmas, except for the prarabdha karma (karma that has begun to bear fruit), are completely destroyed, as if burned away.
The effects of prarabdha karma persist as long as the body exists, requiring the mumukshu to remain in the world. After the death of the body (sharirapat), the liberated soul travels to Brahmaloka via the Devayana path and attains direct realization of Brahma.
Nimbarka does not accept Jivanmukti (liberation while living).
Brahmasvarupa labha does not mean becoming one or identical with Brahma. Instead, it signifies Brahmasayujya labha, meaning becoming similar to Brahma in both nature and attributes.
Atmasvarupa labha implies that in liberation, the jiva's inherent nature does not perish; rather, its true form and qualities reach their ultimate perfection. In this state, the jiva becomes equivalent to Brahma, but not Brahma itself.
The Chandogya Shruti states that the soul, in its true nature, is free from hunger, thirst, old age, sorrow, and sin, and is of true desire and true resolve (satyakama and satyasankalpa). Nimbarka holds that these qualities are only attained by the soul in the state of liberation, not in its ordinary state. Prior to liberation, the jiva's knowing, acting, and experiencing faculties are limited. Though a knower, due to the limited power of body and mind, the jiva is imperfectly knowing and deluded. Though an agent, it is not of true resolve or capable of acting as it pleases. Though an enjoyer, it cannot be fully blissful. However, in liberation, the jiva becomes omniscient, omnipotent, and blissful like Brahma. It becomes a pure conscious entity endowed with auspicious qualities, just like Brahma. The only difference from Brahma remains that it is not omnipresent (vibhu) like Brahma and does not possess the power of creation. The liberated jiva remains atomic (anu), devoid of creative power, and dependent on Brahma.
5. Sadhana (Spiritual Practice)
Nimbarka places great importance on Nishkama Karma (action without desire for results). The proper observance of Varnashrama dharma (duties according to one's social order and stage of life) without attachment purifies the mind (chitta-shuddhi), which, in turn, leads to the emergence of knowledge.
Nimbarka outlines four primary means of spiritual practice:
Jnana (Knowledge) and Atmajnana (Self-knowledge): These are considered means to liberation. Renunciation (sannyasa) is not mandatory for attaining knowledge; a virtuous householder can also achieve it.
Bhakti (Devotion) and Dhyana (Meditation): Meditation is directly a means to moksha. Profound love for God is Bhakti, which is of two types: Para Bhakti (supreme devotion) and Apara Bhakti (lower devotion). While Nimbarka's and Ramanuja's theories of Bhakti are largely similar, Ramanuja's Bhakti is Shraddhamulaka (rooted in reverence, emphasizing divine majesty), whereas Nimbarka's is Pritimulaka (rooted in love, emphasizing divine sweetness/charm). Knowledge-based devotion is Para, and action-based devotion is Apara.
Prapatti (Self-surrender): This involves complete surrender of oneself to Brahma.
Gurupasatti (Surrender to the Guru): This entails complete surrender to the Guru. If a seeker surrenders to the Guru, the Guru Himself leads the disciple to Brahma. Gurupasatti is considered a direct means to liberation. While Jnana and Dhyana are traditionally accessible to higher castes, Prapatti and Gurupasatti are open to individuals of all varnas (social orders).
6. Distinctive Characteristics
The religious philosophy of the Nimbarka Sampradaya is fundamentally based on the distinction or difference between Brahma (the worshipped) and the jiva (the worshipper). This relationship of worshipped-worshipper is eternal, as even in liberation, the jiva remains distinct from Brahma and continues to be its worshipper. As stated, Shri Krishna and Shri Radha Krishna are the worshipped deities in this Sampradaya.
Compared to Ramanuja's system, Nimbarka's philosophy is perhaps less purely philosophical and intellectual ("उतना दर्शनमूलक एवं विचारबहुल नहीं है"). Instead, it is described as being "अधिकार धर्ममूलक एवं भावुकता प्रधान है" (primarily rooted in the religious duties relevant to one's station and driven by emotional devotion), although it does not lack in philosophical discourse.
FAQs
1. What is the Nimbarka Sampradaya and its core philosophical principle?
The Nimbarka Sampradaya is a significant Vaishnava philosophical and religious tradition within Hinduism, founded by Shri Nimbarkacharya. Its core philosophical principle is "Dvaitadvaita" or "Bhedabheda," which translates to "duality-in-non-duality" or "difference and non-difference." This doctrine posits that Brahman (the Supreme Reality), the individual souls (Chit), and the material world (Achit) are simultaneously distinct and non-distinct from each other. They are different in their individual characteristics and functions, yet non-different in their ultimate dependence on and emanation from Brahman, much like a wave is both distinct from and part of the ocean.
2. Who was Shri Nimbarkacharya and what are his key contributions?
Shri Nimbarkacharya is recognized as the founder and principal propounder of the Dvaitadvaita Vedanta philosophy. While historical details about his exact birth period and place are debated among scholars, tradition holds him to be a divine incarnation of Vishnu's Sudarshana Chakra. His primary written contribution is the Vedantaparijata Saurabha, a concise commentary on the Brahma Sutras. His teachings were further elaborated by his disciple, Shri Nivasacharya, in the more extensive Vedanta Kaustubha. Nimbarkacharya's teachings established a distinct path of devotion (bhakti) centered on the worship of Sri Krishna and Sri Radha, emphasizing raganuga bhakti (devotion based on spontaneous affection).
3. What are the three fundamental realities (Tattvas) in Nimbarka's philosophy?
Nimbarka's philosophy is triadic, recognizing three fundamental realities:
Brahman: The Supreme Reality, identified with Krishna. Brahman is considered both the efficient and material cause of the universe. Unlike some other schools, Nimbarka's Brahman is not nirvishesha (without attributes) but savishesha (with attributes), possessing both "fierce" qualities (like omnipotence and rulership) and "sweet" qualities (like beauty, bliss, and compassion). It is active, being the creator, preserver, and destroyer of the world.
Chit (Jiva): Conscious entities, or individual souls. Souls are described as atomic in size, infinite in number, eternal, self-luminous, knowers, doers, and enjoyers. They can be either bound (in samsara) or liberated.
Achit: Unconscious or insentient matter, which is categorized into three types:
Prakrita: Primordial matter from which the material world (samsara) evolves.
Aprakrita: Pure matter that is non-material, forming the divine bodies of Brahman and liberated souls, and the substance of the divine abode.
Kala: Time, which is considered indivisible, all-pervading, immutable, and indestructible.
4. How does Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita explain the relationship between Brahman, Jiva (soul), and Jagat (world)?
Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita asserts that Brahman, Jiva, and Jagat are simultaneously "bhinna" (different) and "abhinna" (non-different) in both their essence (svarupa) and attributes (dharma).
Non-difference (Abheda): From the perspective of cause and effect, power and powerful, and whole and part, they are non-different. The Jiva and Jagat are effects of Brahman, its powers, and its parts, therefore intrinsically connected and dependent on it, similar to how a pot is made of clay and is thus non-different from the clay in its material essence.
Difference (Bheda): Despite this non-difference, each maintains its unique identity and characteristics. Brahman remains Brahman (the Supreme), the Jiva remains an individual soul, and the Jagat remains the material world. For instance, while Jivas are conscious and blissful like Brahman, they lack the power of creation and all-pervasiveness. The inertness of the Jagat is also distinct from Brahman's nature. This inherent, natural, and non-contradictory co-existence of both difference and non-difference is why it's called "Svabhavika Bhedabhedavada" (natural doctrine of difference and non-difference).
5. What is the Nimbarka Sampradaya's concept of liberation (Mukti or Moksha)?
In the Nimbarka Sampradaya, liberation (Mukti or Moksha) involves two aspects: attaining the nature of Brahman (Brahma-svarupa-labha) and realizing one's own true nature (Atma-svarupa-labha). When a seeker (mumukshu) qualifies through spiritual practice and divine grace, all their karmic fruits except for prarabdha karma (karma that has already begun to bear fruit) are destroyed. Liberation is not achieved as long as prarabdha karma keeps the individual in the material world. Upon the fall of the body, the liberated soul reaches Brahmaloka (the abode of Brahman) through the Devayana path and attains the vision of Brahman.
This attainment of Brahman's nature does not mean becoming absolutely one with Brahman, but rather achieving Brahma-sayujya, which means becoming similar to Brahman in essence and attributes. The soul's individuality is not annihilated; instead, its true nature and qualities are fully developed. A liberated soul becomes omniscient, omnipotent, and blissful like Brahman, pure consciousness, and endowed with auspicious qualities. The key distinction is that a liberated soul does not become all-pervading (vibhu) like Brahman and does not gain the power of creation; they remain atomic in nature and dependent on Brahman.
6. What spiritual practices (Sadhana) are emphasized in the Nimbarka Sampradaya for attaining liberation?
The Nimbarka Sampradaya emphasizes four primary spiritual practices for liberation:
Jnana (Knowledge): The knowledge of Brahman and the self is a direct means to liberation. Renunciation (sannyasa) is not strictly necessary; a householder who adheres to righteous conduct can also attain this knowledge.
Bhakti (Devotion) and Dhyana (Meditation): Deep love for God (Bhakti) and meditation are considered direct means to liberation. Bhakti is classified into para bhakti (supreme devotion, rooted in knowledge) and apara bhakti (lower devotion, rooted in action). Nimbarka's bhakti is prītimulaka (based on love and sweetness), emphasizing the affectionate aspect of the divine, as opposed to shraddhamulaka (based on reverence and majesty) as seen in some other traditions.
Prapatti (Self-surrender): Complete self-surrender to Brahman is another significant path.
Gurupasatti (Surrender to the Guru): Absolute surrender to a spiritual teacher (Guru) is highlighted as a direct means to liberation. If a seeker surrenders to the Guru, the Guru guides the disciple towards Brahman. While jnana and dhyana might be more accessible to those of higher varnas, prapatti and gurupasatti are open to all.
7. What is the role of Shri Krishna and Shri Radha in the Nimbarka Sampradaya?
Shri Krishna and Shri Radha are the principal deities worshipped in the Nimbarka Sampradaya. This tradition is a Vaishnava sampradaya, and the worship of the divine couple, Radha-Krishna, is central to its devotional practices, particularly emphasizing raganuga bhakti (devotion stemming from spontaneous affection and love). This focus on the divine couple highlights the sweet and loving aspects of Brahman, underscoring the माधुर्यप्रधान (sweetness-centric) nature of Nimbarka's approach to devotion.
8. How does Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita compare to Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita?
While Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita shares many similarities with Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita, particularly in the understanding of Brahman as saguna (with attributes) and the nature of jiva and jagat as distinct entities dependent on Brahman, a key difference lies in their approach to the concept of "difference" (bheda) and "non-difference" (abheda).
Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita: Affirms that both difference and non-difference are equally true, eternal, natural, and non-contradictory. For Nimbarka, the Jiva and Jagat are simultaneously different from Brahman and non-different from Brahman in their very essence and attributes.
Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita: While also acknowledging both difference and non-difference, Ramanuja's view emphasizes that non-difference (or qualified non-duality) is ultimately more fundamental. In Vishishtadvaita, the Jiva and Jagat are considered attributes (visheshana) of Brahman, existing as an inseparable part of Brahman's body, but distinct in their attributes while non-different in their essential relationship and dependence on Brahman. The difference is subsidiary to the non-difference in Ramanuja's scheme, whereas Nimbarka asserts their co-equal reality.
A Study Guide
This study guide is designed to help you review and deepen your understanding of the Dvaitadvaita Vedanta tradition, particularly as expounded by Nimbarka. It covers its core philosophical tenets, key figures, and unique characteristics.
I. Quiz: Short Answer Questions
Who is considered the main proponent of the Dvaitadvaita Vedanta sampradaya, and what is the name of his commentary on the Brahma Sutras?
The main proponent of the Dvaitadvaita Vedanta sampradaya is Shri Nimbarkacharya. His commentary on the Brahma Sutras is called "Vedantaparijata Saurabha."
What is the core philosophical tenet of Dvaitadvaita Vedanta, and what does it signify regarding the relationship between Brahman, Jiva, and Jagat?
The core philosophical tenet of Dvaitadvaita is bhedabheda or "dvaitadvaita," signifying that Brahman, Jiva (souls), and Jagat (world) are simultaneously different and non-different. This means they are distinct entities but are also inherently related to and dependent on Brahman.
In Nimbarka's philosophy, how is Brahman described, particularly in terms of its attributes and its relationship to the world?
In Nimbarka's philosophy, Brahman is referred to as Krishna and is described as being free from internal and external differences, yet possessing inherent distinctions such as Jiva and Jagat. Brahman is sविशेष (with attributes), सगुण (with qualities), the creator, sustainer, and destroyer of the universe, and both the efficient and material cause.
What are the three types of 'Achit' (insentient matter) identified in Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita system?
The three types of 'Achit' (insentient matter) in Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita are Prakrit (material, like the physical world), Aprakrit (pure, divine matter forming divine bodies and realms), and Kala (time), which is described as indivisible, pervasive, and imperishable.
How does Nimbarka's understanding of "Mukti" (liberation) differ from the concept of "जीवन्मुक्ति" (Jivanmukti)?
Nimbarka does not accept "Jivanmukti" (liberation while living). According to him, liberation occurs after the body perishes, when the liberated soul reaches Brahmaloka (the realm of Brahman) and experiences direct realization of Brahman.
According to Nimbarka, what is the nature of the liberated soul's relationship with Brahman? Does it become identical with Brahman?
The liberated soul in Nimbarka's philosophy does not become one or identical with Brahman. Instead, it attains "Brahmasayujya," meaning it becomes similar to Brahman in nature and qualities, experiencing the full development of its own inherent divine attributes.
Name two primary categories of bhakti (devotion) mentioned in Nimbarka's school, and briefly explain their distinction.
Two primary categories of bhakti are Para Bhakti (superior devotion) and Apara Bhakti (inferior devotion). Para Bhakti is primarily knowledge-based and rooted in deep love for the Lord (Madhurya-pradhan), while Apara Bhakti is action-based, stemming from adherence to prescribed duties (Aishwarya-pradhan).
Besides jnana (knowledge) and bhakti (devotion), what are two other important sadhanas (means to liberation) emphasized by Nimbarka?
Besides jnana (knowledge) and bhakti (devotion), Nimbarka emphasizes prapatti (complete self-surrender to Brahman) and gurupasatti (complete self-surrender to the Guru) as direct means to liberation.
How does the Nimbarka sampradaya's view on the relationship between bheda (difference) and abheda (non-difference) distinguish it from Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita?
While both Nimbarka and Ramanuja accept both difference (bheda) and non-difference (abheda), Nimbarka's "Svabhavika Bhedabhedavada" posits that both are equally true, eternal, and natural. Ramanuja, on the other hand, considers non-difference to be more fundamentally true than difference, with the Jiva and Jagat being attributively different but essentially non-different from Brahman.
What historical challenge exists regarding Nimbarkacharya's biographical details, and what range of opinions do scholars hold about his period of appearance?
There is a lack of definitive historical information regarding Nimbarkacharya's birth period and place. Scholars hold varying opinions, with some placing him after Ramanuja, Madhva, and Vallabhacharya, while others, like George Grierson and Monier Williams, consider his sampradaya to be the oldest among Vaishnava traditions, possibly even preceding Shankaracharya in the 6th-7th century CE.
III. Essay Format Questions
Compare and contrast the philosophical tenets of Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita Vedanta with Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita Vedanta, focusing specifically on their understanding of the relationship between Brahman, Jiva, and Jagat.
Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita Vedanta and Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita Vedanta are both significant philosophical systems within Indian thought, particularly Vedānta, which has been profoundly enriched by the compositions of Vyasa (Badarayana Vyasa's Brahmasutra). While sharing some common ground, they diverge significantly in their understanding of the relationship between Brahman, Jiva (individual soul), and Jagat (material world).
Here's a comparison and contrast of their philosophical tenets:
Commonalities (Shared Tenets):
Three Realities (Tattva-Samiksha): Both Nimbarka and Ramanuja are "Tritvavadi," meaning they acknowledge three fundamental realities: Brahman, Chit (sentient beings or Jiva), and Achit (insentient matter or Jagat).
Nature of Brahman:
Both philosophies assert that Brahman is "Savishesha" (possessing specific attributes) and "Saguna" (possessing qualities), rejecting the notion of a quality-less or attribute-less Brahman (Nirvishesha or Nirguna).
Brahman is described as the source or foundation of both fearsome/powerful qualities (like omnipotence and rulership) and sweet/gracious qualities (like beauty, bliss, and compassion).
Brahman is not inactive or without action; it is the creator, maintainer, and destroyer of the universe.
Brahman is considered both the efficient cause (nimitta karana) and the material cause (upadana karana) of the universe. Therefore, the entire Jiva and Jagat are seen as transformations (parinaama) of Brahman.
In all these points regarding Brahman's nature, Nimbarka's view aligns with Ramanuja's.
Nature of Jiva (Chit):
Both systems define Jiva as a sentient substance.
Jivas are characterized as being inherently knowledgeable (jnanaswarupa) and also knowers (jnata), doers (karta), and enjoyers (bhokta).
Jivas are atomic in size (anu-parinaam) and are numerous (anek) and infinite.
Jivas can be categorized as either bound (baddha) or liberated (mukta).
Nature of Jagat (Achit):
Both Nimbarka and Ramanuja identify three types of insentient matter: Prakrita, Aprakrita, and Kala (Time).
Prakrita refers to the material world created in sequence from Prakriti (cosmic matter).
Aprakrita is a type of pure essence (shuddhatattva) that serves as the material cause for the divine bodies of Brahman and liberated souls, as well as the substances found in Brahmaloka (the divine realm).
Kala (Time) is considered insentient, without parts (amshavihin), omnipresent (vibhu), unchanging (aparinaami), and indestructible (avinashi).
Up to this point, Nimbarka and Ramanuja's views show no significant differences.
Points of Divergence (Key Distinctions):
The primary difference lies in their specific interpretation of the relationship between Brahman, Jiva, and Jagat.
Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita (Dvaitadvaita / Bhedabheda):
Core Principle: Nimbarka's doctrine is called Dvaitadvaita (dualistic non-dualism) or Bhedabheda (difference and non-difference). It posits that Brahman and the Jiva-Jagat (creation) are "Bhinna-Abhinna" (different yet non-different), both in their intrinsic nature (swarupa) and their attributes (dharma).
Explanation of Bhinna-Abhinna: This concept means they are both different and non-different simultaneously.
Non-Difference (Abheda): Brahman is the cause, and Jiva-Jagat are its effects; Brahman is the powerful, and Jiva-Jagat are its power; Brahman is the whole, and Jiva-Jagat are its parts. Just as a pot is made of clay (cause and effect are inseparable in terms of material), Brahman and Jiva-Jagat are considered non-different in terms of their material origin. Jivas are also non-different from Brahman in being conscious and blissful, and both Jiva and Jagat are considered true and eternal like Brahman.
Difference (Bheda): Despite their non-difference, Brahman's "Brahman-ness," Jiva's "Jiva-ness," and Jagat's "Jagat-ness" remain distinct; Brahman is not Jiva or Jagat. Jivas do not possess all the qualities of Brahman, such as the power of creation, omnipresence (Vibhutva), or indestructibility. Jivas possess qualities like atomicity (anutva), engagement in desire-driven actions (sakaam karma), and experiencing results (phalabhoga), which are not present in Brahman. The inertness (jadvata) of Jagat is also a distinct quality not found in Brahman.
Equality of Truth: For Nimbarka, both difference (bheda) and non-difference (abheda) are equally true, eternal, natural, and non-contradictory. This is why his philosophy is specifically referred to as "Svabhavika Bhedabhedavada" (Natural Doctrine of Difference and Non-difference).
Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita (Qualified Non-dualism):
Core Principle: While Ramanuja also acknowledges both difference and non-difference, his key distinction is that non-difference (abheda) is considered more true than difference (bheda).
Relationship Interpretation: In Vishishtadvaita, Jiva and Jagat are understood as modes (vishesha) or attributes of Brahman, forming an inseparable unity. They are distinct from Brahman in their attributes (dharmataḥ bhinna) but are non-different in their essential nature (swarupa-taḥ abhinna), meaning they cannot exist independently of Brahman, much like attributes cannot exist without a substance. This implies a complex, organic unity where Brahman is the qualified whole, and Jiva and Jagat are its integral, dependent parts, always existing with Brahman.
In essence, while both Nimbarka and Ramanuja advocate a qualified non-dualism where Brahman is endowed with attributes and is the cause of the universe, their fundamental divergence lies in the weight and nature of the difference (bheda) and non-difference (abheda). Nimbarka maintains that both aspects are equally real and inherent, while Ramanuja emphasizes the overarching non-duality where Jiva and Jagat are inseparable attributes of Brahman, with non-difference being the superior truth.
Discuss the concept of Brahman in Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita philosophy. Explain how Nimbarka reconciles Brahman's nature as being without internal or external भेद (differences) while still possessing स्वगत भेद (inherent distinctions) like Jiva and Jagat.
Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita Vedanta offers a unique understanding of Brahman, specifically in its reconciliation of Brahman's transcendent nature with its immanent presence as Jiva (individual soul) and Jagat (material world).
The Concept of Brahman in Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita
In Nimbarka's philosophical system, Brahman is referred to as Krishna. This Brahman is unequivocally described as "Savishesha" (possessing specific attributes) and "Saguna" (possessing qualities), rejecting the notion of a quality-less or attribute-less Brahman found in other schools of Vedanta. Brahman is the source or foundation of both fearsome/powerful qualities (such as omnipotence and rulership) and sweet/gracious qualities (like beauty, bliss, and compassion). Furthermore, Brahman is not inactive; it is the creator, maintainer, and destroyer of the universe. It functions as both the efficient cause (nimitta karana) and the material cause (upadana karana) of the universe, implying that the entire Jiva and Jagat are considered transformations (parinaama) of Brahman. In these aspects of Brahman's nature, Nimbarka's view aligns significantly with Ramanuja's.
Reconciling Differences and Non-Differences in Brahman
The unique contribution of Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita (dualistic non-dualism) or Bhedabheda (difference and non-difference) lies in its explanation of how Brahman can be understood as both distinct from and non-distinct from Jiva and Jagat simultaneously.
Nimbarka asserts that Brahman is devoid of "sajatiya" (homogeneous) and "vijatiya" (heterogeneous) differences. This means Brahman has no equal (no other Brahman) and is not fundamentally different from anything outside its own category.
However, Nimbarka posits that Brahman possesses "svagata bheda" (inherent distinctions), meaning that Jiva (individual soul) and Jagat (material world) are its intrinsic or inherent differences. This is where the core of Nimbarka's reconciliation, the Bhinna-Abhinna (different-non-different) relationship, comes into play. This concept means that Brahman and Jiva-Jagat are simultaneously different and non-different, both in their intrinsic nature (swarupa) and their attributes (dharma).
Non-Difference (Abheda):
Nimbarka explains non-difference through the analogy of cause and effect, the powerful and its power, or the whole and its parts. Just as a pot made of clay is materially inseparable from the clay (the cause and effect are one in terms of material), Brahman and Jiva-Jagat are considered non-different in their fundamental origin and substance.
Jivas are considered non-different from Brahman in their essential qualities of consciousness (chetan) and bliss (anandamay).
Crucially, both Jiva and Jagat are regarded as true (satya) and eternal (nitya), just like Brahman itself. This underscores their inseparable and real existence within Brahman.
Difference (Bheda):
Despite this non-difference, Nimbarka emphasizes that the distinct identities of Brahman, Jiva, and Jagat are also equally real. Brahman's "Brahman-ness," Jiva's "Jiva-ness," and Jagat's "Jagat-ness" remain separate and distinct. Brahman is Brahman; it is not Jiva or Jagat.
Distinct Attributes: While Jivas share consciousness and bliss with Brahman, they do not possess all of Brahman's qualities, such as the power of creation, omnipresence (Vibhutva), or indestructibility. Instead, Jivas have their own unique qualities, such as being atomic in size (anutva), engaging in desire-driven actions (sakaam karma), and experiencing the results of those actions (phalabhoga), which are not present in Brahman. Similarly, the inertness (jadvata) of Jagat is a quality distinct from Brahman.
For Nimbarka, both difference (bheda) and non-difference (abheda) are considered equally true, eternal, natural, and non-contradictory. This is the essence of his "Svabhavika Bhedabhedavada" (Natural Doctrine of Difference and Non-difference).
Distinction from Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita
While both Nimbarka and Ramanuja acknowledge difference and non-difference, their primary divergence lies in the emphasis placed on these two aspects. Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita (Qualified Non-dualism) considers non-difference (abheda) to be more true than difference (bheda). In Ramanuja's view, Jiva and Jagat are integral modes or attributes of Brahman, forming an inseparable unity that cannot exist independently of Brahman. They are distinct by attributes but non-different in their essential nature as dependent parts of Brahman. Nimbarka, however, maintains that both difference and non-difference are equally real and inherent aspects of the relationship between Brahman and its creation.
Elaborate on the Dvaitadvaita understanding of mukti (liberation). What are its two components, and how does the state of the liberated soul reflect both its similarity to and continued distinction from Brahman?
In Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita philosophy, the concept of mukti or liberation is understood as a profound transformation that involves both similarity to and a continued distinction from Brahman. Nimbarka's system does not accept jivanmukti (liberation while living).
Components of Mukti (Liberation)
According to Nimbarka, mukti comprises two distinct but interrelated components:
Brahmaswarupa Labha (Attainment of Brahman's Nature):
This component signifies that the liberated individual soul (Jiva) attains a nature and attributes similar to Brahman, rather than becoming entirely one or identical with Brahman.
The path to this liberation involves the purification of the mind through selfless action (nishkam karma), which leads to the acquisition of knowledge.
Upon reaching the appropriate stage of spiritual practice and through Brahman's grace, all of the aspirant's karmic fruits, except for the prarabdha karma (the portion of karma responsible for the current body), are utterly destroyed.
As long as the prarabdha karma persists, the aspirant remains in the material world. However, after the demise of the physical body (शरीरपात), the soul travels along the Devayana Marga to Brahmaloka, where it directly experiences or realizes Brahman.
Atmaswarupa Labha (Attainment of Self's Nature):
This aspect emphasizes the complete development and ultimate perfection of the soul's inherent nature and qualities in the state of liberation. Liberation does not involve the destruction of the soul's individuality but rather its full unfolding.
The Chandogya Shruti, cited by Nimbarka, states that in this liberated state, the soul becomes free from hunger, thirst, old age, sorrow, and sin, and becomes truth-willed (satyakama) and truth-resolving (satyasankalpa). These qualities are realized in liberation, not in the ordinary state of existence.
Similarity to and Continued Distinction from Brahman
Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita uniquely reconciles the soul's transformation with its enduring distinctiveness:
Similarity (Abheda - Non-Difference in essence):
In the liberated state, the Jiva, like Brahman, becomes pure consciousness (shuddha chetan) and is endowed with auspicious qualities (kalyana gunas).
The liberated soul attains states that mirror Brahman's perfections: it becomes all-knowing (sarvajna), all-powerful (sarvashaktiman), and entirely blissful (anandamaya), much like Brahman. This signifies a profound resemblance in attributes and nature (swarupataḥ evan dharmataḥ Brahma ke sadrish), fulfilling the "Brahmaswarupa Labha".
The Jiva is non-different from Brahman in being conscious and blissful, and both Jiva and Jagat are considered true and eternal like Brahman.
Continued Distinction (Bheda - Difference in inherent characteristics):
Despite achieving profound similarity, Nimbarka explicitly states that the liberated soul does not become Brahman itself. The "Brahman-ness" of Brahman and the "Jiva-ness" of the Jiva remain distinct.
The primary distinctions are:
The liberated Jiva remains atomic in size (anu), unlike Brahman which is all-pervading (vibhu).
The liberated Jiva does not possess the power of creation (srishti shakti).
Crucially, even in liberation, the liberated soul remains subservient to Brahman (Brahma ke adhin rahata hai). This maintains the eternal worshipped-worshipper (upasya-upasaka) relationship between Brahman (Krishna) and the Jiva, which is a fundamental tenet of the Nimbarka Sampradaya and is based on their inherent difference.
Nimbarka's unique contribution lies in asserting that both difference (bheda) and non-difference (abheda) are equally true, eternal, natural, and non-contradictory. This is why his philosophy is known as "Svabhavika Bhedabhedavada" (Natural Doctrine of Difference and Non-difference). In contrast to Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita, where non-difference is considered more fundamentally true than difference, Nimbarka gives equal weight to both aspects, even in the ultimate state of liberation.
Analyze the role of sadhanas (spiritual practices) in the Nimbarka sampradaya. Discuss the four main types mentioned and explain how they contribute to the practitioner's journey towards liberation.
In Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita philosophy, sadhanas (spiritual practices) play a central and indispensable role in the practitioner's journey towards mukti (liberation). The process begins with specific prerequisites: a seeker of liberation (mumukshu) must first study the Shadanga Veda and Dharma Mimamsa (Purva Mimamsa). Following this, the seeker, characterized by devotion to their guru (gurubhakta), dispassion (vairagyavan), and a desire for divine grace (Bhagavatkripakankshi), becomes qualified to hear Vedanta (Vedanta shravana ke adhikari hote hain).
Role of Sadhanas
Nimbarka emphasizes that selfless action (nishkam karma) is paramount in the sadhana path. By strictly adhering to the Varnashrama Dharma without any desire for personal gain, the practitioner achieves purity of mind (chitta shuddhi), which in turn leads to the generation of knowledge (gyan ki utpatti ka karan banti hai). This purified state of mind is essential for further spiritual progress.
Four Main Types of Sadhanas
Nimbarka identifies four primary sadhanas that guide the aspirant towards liberation:
Jnana (Knowledge) and Dhyana (Meditation):
Knowledge of Brahman (Brahmagyan) and knowledge of the self (Atmagyan) are both considered direct means (sakshat rup se moksha ka upay) for attaining liberation.
Nimbarka states that renunciation (sanyas) is not mandatory for acquiring this knowledge; a virtuous householder (sadachari grihastha) can also achieve it.
Similarly, meditation (Dhyana) is also regarded as a direct means to liberation, on par with knowledge.
Bhakti (Devotion):
Bhakti is defined as profound love for God (gambhira Bhagavatpreeti).
It is categorized into two types:
Para Bhakti (higher devotion): This is knowledge-based (gyanamulak Bhakti).
Apara Bhakti (lower devotion): This is action-based (karmamulak Bhakti).
Nimbarka's concept of Bhakti is primarily love-oriented (preeti-mulak), emphasizing the sweetness (madhurya) of devotion. This contrasts with Ramanuja's Bhakti, which is more faith-based (shraddhamulak) and focuses on the majesty (aishwarya) of God, although Nimbarka notes that there isn't significant disagreement between the two schools on the general principle of Bhakti.
Prapatti (Complete Surrender to Brahman):
Prapatti involves total self-surrender to Brahman (Brahma ke prati sampoorna atmasamarpan).
Crucially, this path of surrender is accessible to all varnas (sabhi varna adhikari hain), unlike Jnana and Dhyana which might imply a higher social or intellectual qualification.
Gurupasatti (Surrender to Guru):
Gurupasatti signifies complete self-surrender to the Guru (Guru ke prati atmasamarpan).
Nimbarka asserts that if a seeker surrenders to the Guru, the Guru himself leads the disciple directly to Brahman (Guru hi shishya ko Brahma ke pas pahunchate hain), making it a direct means of liberation (sakshat rup se mukti ka upay).
Like Prapatti, Gurupasatti is also open to all varnas.
Contribution to Liberation
Through these sadhanas, the practitioner progresses towards mukti, which in Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita is understood to have two components:
Brahmaswarupa Labha (Attainment of Brahman's Nature): The disciplined practice of sadhanas purifies the soul, leading to the destruction of all karmic fruits except prarabdha karma (the portion of karma currently being experienced). After the physical body perishes (sharirpat), the soul ascends through the Devayana Marga to Brahmaloka, where it directly realizes Brahman (Brahm ka sakshatkar karte hain). This realization is not an absorption into Brahman to become identical, but rather the attainment of similarity to Brahman in nature and attributes (swarupataḥ evan dharmataḥ Brahma ke sadrish).
Atmaswarupa Labha (Attainment of Self's Nature): Liberation leads to the complete development and perfection of the soul's inherent nature and qualities. The liberated soul becomes free from hunger, thirst, old age, sorrow, and sin, and gains qualities like being truth-willed (satyakama) and truth-resolving (satyasankalpa). In this state, the soul becomes all-knowing (sarvajna), all-powerful (sarvashaktiman), and entirely blissful (anandamaya), mirroring Brahman. It is pure consciousness (shuddha chetan) and endowed with auspicious qualities (kalyana gunas).
Despite this profound similarity and shared attributes, Nimbarka maintains a crucial distinction: the liberated soul does not become Brahman itself. The "Brahman-ness" of Brahman and the "Jiva-ness" of the individual soul remain separate and real. The liberated soul remains atomic in size (anu), does not possess the power of creation (srishti shakti), and most importantly, remains subservient to Brahman (Brahma ke adhin rahata hai). This enduring distinction upholds the eternal worshipped-worshipper (upasya-upasaka) relationship between Brahman (Krishna) and the Jiva, which is a fundamental tenet of the Nimbarka Sampradaya and is based on their inherent difference. Thus, sadhanas in Nimbarka's philosophy facilitate a transformative journey where the soul achieves an intimate resemblance to Brahman while preserving its distinct, dependent individuality.
Despite historical uncertainties regarding Nimbarkacharya's life, his philosophical system significantly influenced Indian thought. Discuss the importance and unique contributions of the Dvaitadvaita Vedanta sampradaya to the broader landscape of Indian philosophy and Vaishnavism.
Despite historical uncertainties surrounding Nimbarkacharya's exact birth period and place, his philosophical system, known as Dvaitadvaita Vedanta, made significant and unique contributions to the broader landscape of Indian philosophy and Vaishnavism.
Importance of Dvaitadvaita Vedanta Sampradaya
The Dvaitadvaita Vedanta sampradaya holds a crucial place among the various religious and philosophical traditions that were influenced by and built upon the interpretations of Vedanta philosophy, particularly the Brahmasutras of Badarayana Vyasa. Nimbarka's own concise commentary, Vedantaparijat Saurabha, combined with his disciple Srinivasacharya's more extensive Vedantakaustubha, provides a comprehensive philosophical framework.
Unique Contributions to Indian Philosophy
Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita (also known as Bhedabhedavada or Svabhavika Bhedabhedavada) uniquely reconciles the concepts of difference and non-difference, asserting them as equally real and fundamental.
Svabhavika Bhedabhedavada (Natural Doctrine of Difference and Non-difference): This is Nimbarka's most distinctive philosophical contribution. He posits that both difference (bheda) and non-difference (abheda) are equally true, eternal, natural, and non-contradictory. This stands in contrast to Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita, which, while accepting both, prioritizes non-difference as more fundamentally true. Nimbarka illustrates this with the analogy of a pot made of clay: the pot (effect) is non-different from the clay (cause) in essence, yet it is distinct in form, function, and individual existence. Similarly, Jiva (individual soul) and Jagat (world) are both non-different from Brahman (the cause) as its effects and powers, yet they remain inherently distinct in their "Jiva-ness" and "Jagat-ness" from Brahman's "Brahman-ness".
Understanding of Brahman: In Nimbarka's system, Brahman is identified with Krishna. This Brahman is understood as possessing specific attributes (savishesha) and qualities (saguna), rather than being featureless (nirvishesha). Crucially, while Brahman is free from homogeneous and heterogeneous differences, it possesses internal (svagata) differences in the form of Jiva and Jagat. Brahman is both the efficient (nimitta) and material (upadana) cause of the world, meaning the entire Jiva and Jagat are its direct outcome. Brahman encompasses both fierce (bhishana) qualities (like omnipotence and rulership) and sweet (madhura) qualities (like beauty, bliss, and compassion).
Nature of Liberated Soul (Mukta Jiva): Dvaitadvaita's understanding of mukti (liberation) has two components: Brahmaswarupa Labha and Atmaswarupa Labha.
Brahmaswarupa Labha signifies that the liberated soul attains a nature and attributes similar to Brahman. The liberated soul becomes pure consciousness (shuddha chetan) and is endowed with auspicious qualities (kalyana gunas). It achieves states like being all-knowing (sarvajna), all-powerful (sarvashaktiman), and entirely blissful (anandamaya), much like Brahman.
Atmaswarupa Labha emphasizes the complete development and ultimate perfection of the soul's inherent nature and qualities. The liberated soul becomes free from hunger, thirst, old age, sorrow, and sin, and gains qualities such as being truth-willed (satyakama) and truth-resolving (satyasankalpa).
However, a key distinction from non-dualistic schools is maintained: the liberated soul does not become identical with Brahman. The liberated soul remains atomic in size (anu), does not possess the power of creation (srishti shakti), and most importantly, remains subservient to Brahman (Brahma ke adhin rahata hai). Nimbarka does not accept jivanmukti (liberation while living).
Role of Nishkam Karma (Selfless Action): Nimbarka places great importance on selfless action (performing duties according to Varnashrama Dharma without desire for results) as a fundamental sadhana. This practice purifies the mind (chitta shuddhi), which in turn leads to the generation of knowledge (gyan ki utpatti ka karan banti hai).
Contributions to Vaishnavism
The Nimbarka Sampradaya is fundamentally a Vaishnava tradition, deeply influencing the devotional landscape of India.
Supremacy of Radha-Krishna Worship: A defining characteristic is its unique emphasis on Shri Krishna and Shri Radha as the supreme deities (Upasya). This explicit and primary focus on Radha alongside Krishna is a pioneering contribution that later profoundly influenced other Vaishnava traditions, particularly those emphasizing the sweet aspect of the Divine.
Preeti-mulak Bhakti (Love-oriented Devotion): Nimbarka's conception of Bhakti is primarily love-oriented (preeti-mulak), focusing on the sweetness (madhurya) of profound love for God (gambhira Bhagavatpreeti). This contrasts with Ramanuja's more faith-based, majesty-oriented (aishwarya-pradhan) Bhakti, though the schools generally agree on the principle of devotion. This emotional and affectionate approach resonated deeply within Vaishnava spirituality.
Eternal Worshipped-Worshipper Relationship: A core tenet of the Nimbarka Sampradaya is that the relationship between Brahman (the worshipped) and the Jiva (the worshipper) is eternal and distinct. Even after liberation, the Jiva remains a worshipper of Brahman, preserving its individuality and the devotional dynamic. This perpetuates the loving service of the Lord.
Inclusivity of Sadhanas: While Jnana (knowledge) and Dhyana (meditation) may imply higher qualifications, Nimbarka offers the sadhanas of Prapatti (complete surrender to Brahman) and Gurupasatti (complete surrender to the Guru), both of which are accessible to all varnas. This inclusiveness allowed a wider segment of society to pursue the path to liberation, making spiritual practice more democratic.
Divine Guru-Parampara: The sampradaya emphasizes a divinely revealed lineage (guru-parampara) beginning with Lord Hamsa (Narayana), who taught the Sanatkumars, who in turn taught Narada, and then Narada taught Nimbarkacharya. This unbroken and divinely sanctioned lineage provides strong traditional authority and continuity to the sampradaya's teachings and practices.
In essence, Nimbarka's Dvaitadvaita stands as a sophisticated yet devotionally rich system that provided a unique resolution to the philosophical debates surrounding the nature of ultimate reality, individual souls, and the world, deeply enriching both Indian philosophy and the diverse traditions of Vaishnavism.
IV. Glossary of Key Terms
Acharya (आचार्य): A revered teacher or preceptor, particularly in a spiritual or philosophical tradition.
Achit (अचित्): Insentient or inanimate matter; the non-conscious principle in Nimbarka's philosophy, categorized into Prakrit, Aprakrit, and Kala.
Abheda (अभेद): Non-difference; the concept of unity or identity between two entities.
Aishwarya-pradhan (ऐश्वर्यप्रधान): Emphasizing majesty, power, and divine sovereignty; a characteristic of certain types of devotion (e.g., Ramanuja's bhakti).
Apara Bhakti (अपरा भक्ति): Inferior or lower devotion; often described as karma-based or focused on prescribed actions.
Anu (अणु): Minute or atomic; referring to the small size of the individual soul (Jiva) in Nimbarka's philosophy.
Anshī (अंशी): The whole; that which possesses parts. Brahman is the Anshi, while Jiva and Jagat are its Ansha (parts).
Badaarayana Vyaas (बादरायण व्यास): The revered sage traditionally credited with composing the Brahma Sutras and other foundational texts of Indian philosophy.
Bheda (भेद): Difference; the concept of distinction or separateness between two entities.
Bhedabheda (भेदाभेद): Simultaneous difference and non-difference; the core philosophical tenet of Dvaitadvaita, asserting that Brahman and its effects (Jiva and Jagat) are both distinct from and identical to it.
Brahman (ब्रह्मन्): The ultimate reality, the Supreme Being, the absolute truth in Hindu philosophy. In Nimbarka's system, identified with Krishna.
Brahma Sutras (ब्रह्मसूत्र): A foundational text of the Vedanta school of Hindu philosophy, consisting of aphorisms summarizing the teachings of the Upanishads.
Brahma-Saakshaatkaar (ब्रह्मसाक्षात्कार): Direct realization or experience of Brahman.
Brahmasayujya (ब्रह्मसायुज्य): Attaining similarity with Brahman; a state of liberation where the soul is like Brahman in nature and qualities, but not identical.
Chit (चित्): Conscious principle; referring to the individual soul (Jiva) in Nimbarka's philosophy.
Devayaan Maarg (देवयान मार्ग): The path of the gods; a celestial path taken by liberated souls to reach Brahmaloka.
Dvaitadvaita (द्वैताद्वैत): Literally "dualistic non-dualism" or "dualism-non-dualism"; Nimbarka's philosophy emphasizing the simultaneous difference and non-difference between Brahman, Jiva, and Jagat.
Guru (गुरु): A spiritual teacher or preceptor.
Gurupasatti (गुरुपसत्ति): Complete self-surrender to the Guru as a means to liberation.
Hansa Sampraday (हंस संप्रदाय): Another name for the Nimbarka sampradaya, referring to the tradition that Lord Vishnu in the form of a swan (Hamsa) taught the four Kumaras.
Jagat (जगत्): The universe, the world; sentient and insentient creation.
Jiva (जीव): The individual soul; a conscious entity that is a part of Brahman.
Jivanmukti (जीवन्मुक्ति): Liberation while living; the state of being liberated from the cycle of birth and death while still embodied. Nimbarka does not accept this.
Jnana (ज्ञान): Knowledge; especially spiritual knowledge leading to liberation.
Kala (काल): Time; one of the three types of Achit in Nimbarka's philosophy.
Karma (कर्म): Action, deed; also the consequences of actions, which bind the soul to the cycle of rebirth.
Krishna (कृष्ण): A principal deity in Hinduism, revered as the Supreme Being in the Nimbarka Sampradaya and identified with Brahman.
Madurya-pradhan (माधुर्यप्रधान): Emphasizing sweetness, charm, and loving intimacy; a characteristic of certain types of devotion (e.g., Nimbarka's bhakti).
Mukti (मुक्ति): Liberation; release from the cycle of birth and death (samsara).
Mumukshu (मुमुक्षु): One who desires liberation.
Nimitta Kaaran (निमित्त कारण): Efficient cause; the agent or designer of creation (e.g., Brahman creating the world).
Para Bhakti (परा भक्ति): Superior or higher devotion; often described as knowledge-based and characterized by profound love for the divine.
Prakrit (प्राकृत): Material; originating from Prakriti (primordial nature), referring to the material world.
Prapatti (प्रपत्ति): Complete surrender or refuge to the divine.
Prarabdha Karma (प्रारब्ध कर्म): That part of accumulated karma that has begun to bear fruit and is responsible for the present life.
Raagāanugā Bhakti (रागानुगा भक्ति): Devotion following the spontaneous love and attachment (raga) of the eternal associates of Radha-Krishna.
Radha (राधा): The chief consort of Krishna, revered as the divine feminine in the Nimbarka Sampradaya.
Ramanuja (रामानुज): A prominent philosopher and proponent of the Vishishtadvaita (qualified non-dualism) school of Vedanta.
Sadhanā (साधना): Spiritual practice or means to achieve a goal, especially liberation.
Saguna (सगुण): With attributes; referring to Brahman as possessing divine qualities.
Sakha (सखा): Friend; one of the relationships in which devotion (bhakti) can be expressed.
Sampradaya (संप्रदाय): A traditional system of religious or philosophical teaching, a lineage of teachers and disciples.
San Sampradaya (सन संप्रदाय): Another name for the Nimbarka sampradaya, referring to the four Kumaras (Sanaka, Sanandana, Sanatana, Sanatkumara) as its original teachers.
Sashakti (सशक्ति): Possessing power; referring to Brahman as having divine power.
Savishesh (सविशेष): With specific characteristics or distinctions; referring to Brahman as possessing attributes rather than being undifferentiated.
Shakti (शक्ति): Power, energy; referring to Jiva and Jagat as the power or energy of Brahman.
Shankaracharya (शंकराचार्य): A renowned philosopher and the main proponent of the Advaita Vedanta (non-dualism) school.
Shrinivasacharya (श्रीनिवासाचार्य): A direct disciple of Nimbarkacharya, who wrote a more extensive commentary on Nimbarka's philosophy called "Vedanta Kaustubha."
Svagat Bheda (स्वगत भेद): Internal difference; inherent distinctions within a single entity (e.g., Brahman having Jiva and Jagat as its internal distinctions).
Svabhavika Bhedabhedavada (स्वाभाविक भेदाभेदवाद): Nimbarka's specific doctrine, emphasizing that difference and non-difference are naturally, eternally, and equally true.
Tattva (तत्त्व): Truth, reality, principle. In Nimbarka's system, the three fundamental Tattvas are Brahman, Chit, and Achit.
Upaadaan Kaaran (उपादान कारण): Material cause; the substance from which something is made (e.g., clay as the material cause of a pot).
Upaasya (उपास्य): The object of worship; the deity or ultimate reality that is worshipped.
Upaasak (उपासक): The worshipper or devotee.
Vedanta (वेदान्त): One of the six orthodox schools of Hindu philosophy, primarily concerned with the nature of ultimate reality (Brahman) and the individual soul (Atman).
Vedantaparijata Saurabha (वेदान्तपारिजातसौरभ): Nimbarkacharya's commentary on the Brahma Sutras.
Vedanta Kaustubha (वेदान्तकौस्तुभ): The more extensive commentary on Nimbarka's philosophy written by his disciple, Shrinivasacharya.
Vibhu (विभु): All-pervading, omnipresent; a quality of Brahman, but not of liberated souls (Jivas).
Vishishtadvaita (विशिष्टाद्वैत): Qualified non-dualism; the philosophical school of Ramanuja, asserting that Brahman is a qualified non-dual entity with Jivas and Jagat as its attributes.
No comments:
Post a Comment